Landlord insurance California: cost with earthquake cover

Landlord insurance in California often means a dwelling quote plus a separate earthquake policy, because earthquake is usually excluded. On the example $3,200-a-month rental, a $2,600 quote and a $1,500 earthquake policy take 10.7% of the rent, against 6.8% without earthquake cover.

Worksheet US-5

What landlord and earthquake cover cost on your rental

Enter the annual premium from each quote and your earthquake premium

The rental

$
%
$
$

Your quotes (annual premium)

$
$
$
$

Tax

Deduct the premiums as rental expenses?
%
Insurance takes10.7%of a year's rent: $341.67 a month (quote 1, the lowest)
Weeks of rent5.6to pay the premium
Net yield after insurance2.42%2.95% before
After-tax cost$2,747if deductible at 33%
QuotePremium a yearPer month% of rentNet yield after
Quote 1$4,100$341.6710.7%2.42%
Quote 2$4,900$408.3312.8%2.32%

The highest quote costs $800 a year more than the lowest. Compare what each covers (building, contents, loss of rent, tenant damage, liability, excess) before comparing price.

Year one
Rent for the year$38,400
Less: Vacancy($1,920)
Rent collected$36,480
Less: Other running costs($13,500)
Net income before insurance$22,980
Less: Landlord policy (lowest quote)($2,600)
Less: Earthquake policy($1,500)
Net income after insurance$18,880

Gross yield 4.92%. Net yield, which is also the cap rate on the price, falls by 0.53 percentage points with this premium.

Formula. Total premium = landlord quote + earthquake policy. Share of rent = total ÷ (monthly rent × 12). Cap rate after insurance = (rent × (1 − vacancy) − operating costs − total) ÷ value.

On this page
  1. Earthquake cover for a California rental
  2. The California FAIR Plan for landlords
  3. Why California quotes are changing
  4. Is landlord insurance tax deductible in California?
  5. FAQ
  6. Sources

Earthquake cover for a California rental

Earthquake is one of the perils the California Department of Insurance lists as usually excluded from a standard policy.[1] For homeowners policies, the insurer is "legally obligated to offer you earthquake coverage for an additional premium", and that cover may come from the same insurer, a separate insurer or the California Earthquake Authority (CEA).[1] The CEA sells residential policies through insurance partners for homeowners, condo unit owners, mobilehome owners and renters;[4] for a rental you own but do not live in, ask the dwelling insurer which earthquake options it offers. The table prices the example with and without it.

The example (inputs, not market data)
Without earthquakeWith earthquake
Lowest landlord quote$2,600$2,600
Earthquake policy–$1,500
Total premium$2,600$4,100
Share of $38,400 rent6.8%10.7%
Cap rate after insurance2.61%2.42%

The California FAIR Plan for landlords

If standard insurers will not write the property, the California FAIR Plan is the fallback. It is an association of all property insurers licensed in California, and it "offers a standard fire insurance policy for both the structure and contents", a basic policy with coverage limitations; "No coverage is provided for liability or coverage for other perils such as burglary."[1] A rental on the FAIR Plan therefore needs liability cover from another policy. Enter the FAIR Plan premium plus any policy you buy to fill its gaps as one quote, so the comparison with a full dwelling policy is like for like; landlord insurance policies explains what the DP-1, DP-2 and DP-3 dwelling forms cover.

Why California quotes are changing

Under its Sustainable Insurance Strategy, the Department of Insurance requires major insurers that use the new rules to write comprehensive policies in wildfire distressed areas equal to at least 85% of their statewide market share.[3] The department's strategy page reports 12 homeowners insurance groups expanding in California, 677,449 FAIR Plan homeowner policies and 662 ZIP codes counted as distressed areas.[2] If your rental is in one of those areas, get a new standard quote at each renewal and compare it with the FAIR Plan route in the worksheet.

Is landlord insurance tax deductible in California?

For federal tax, insurance is one of the rental expenses IRS Publication 527 allows you to deduct, and a premium paid more than a year ahead is deducted year by year.[5] At the example's 33% combined rate, the $4,100 total costs $2,747 after tax. California rentals also face Prop 13 reassessment and rent caps; the cap rate California calculator redoes a listing's NOI for both. Other states: Florida landlord insurance (hurricane deductibles) and New Jersey landlord insurance (flood cover); the landlord insurance quote calculator compares quotes in any state.

Not adviceWe are not an insurer or broker. We do not sell, compare or arrange insurance, we do not rank insurers, and no insurer pays us. This page is general information, not insurance, tax or legal advice. In the US each state's insurance department licenses insurers and agents; check a company or agent with your state's department before you buy. See the investment disclaimer.

Frequently asked questions

How much is landlord insurance in California?

No official body publishes an average landlord premium for California. Enter the quotes you receive, and any earthquake premium, in the worksheet to see the total as a share of rent and its effect on the cap rate.

Does landlord insurance in California cover earthquakes?

Usually not. Earthquake is a standard exclusion; it is bought as separate cover from the insurer, another insurer or, for homeowners, condo owners, mobilehome owners and renters, the California Earthquake Authority.

Can a rental property go on the California FAIR Plan?

The FAIR Plan writes a basic fire policy for the structure and contents when standard insurers decline. It does not include liability, so a landlord needs that from another policy.

Is California landlord insurance tax deductible?

For federal tax, insurance on a rental is a deductible rental expense under IRS Publication 527. The worksheet shows the after-tax cost at your combined rate.

Sources

  1. Residential Insurance: Homeowners and Renters · California Department of Insurance, accessed November 16, 2026
  2. Sustainable Insurance Strategy · California Department of Insurance, accessed November 16, 2026
  3. Commissioner Lara announces enforcement of regulation to expand insurance coverage across state (release 062-2024) · California Department of Insurance, 2024
  4. How to Buy Earthquake Insurance in California · California Earthquake Authority, accessed November 16, 2026
  5. Publication 527 (2025), Residential Rental Property · Internal Revenue Service, for 2025 returns