Landlord insurance quote calculator

A landlord insurance quote is easiest to judge against your rent: on the example $2,000-a-month rental, a $1,420 annual quote takes 5.9% of the rent ($118.33 a month) and, deducted as a rental expense, costs $1,108 after tax in the 22% bracket.

Worksheet US-1

What your landlord insurance quote costs you

Enter the annual premium from each quote you received

The rental

$
%
$
$

Your quotes (annual premium)

$
$
$

Tax

Deduct the premium as a rental expense?
%
Insurance takes5.9%of a year's rent: $118.33 a month (quote 2, the lowest)
Weeks of rent3.1to pay the premium
Net yield after insurance5.53%6.00% before
After-tax cost$1,108if deductible at 22%
QuotePremium a yearPer month% of rentNet yield after
Quote 1$1,650$137.506.9%5.45%
Quote 2$1,420$118.335.9%5.53%

The highest quote costs $230 a year more than the lowest. Compare what each covers (building, contents, loss of rent, tenant damage, liability, excess) before comparing price.

Year one
Rent for the year$24,000
Less: Vacancy($1,200)
Rent collected$22,800
Less: Other running costs($4,800)
Net income before insurance$18,000
Less: Insurance premium($1,420)
Net income after insurance$16,580

Gross yield 8.00%. Net yield, which is also the cap rate on the price, falls by 0.47 percentage points with this premium.

Formula. Share of rent = premium ÷ (monthly rent × 12). Cap rate after insurance = (rent × (1 − vacancy) − operating costs − premium) ÷ value. After-tax cost = premium × (1 − marginal rate) when you deduct it.

On this page
  1. What a landlord insurance quote costs you
  2. Is landlord insurance tax deductible?
  3. What to have ready for a landlord insurance quote
  4. How to compare landlord insurance quotes
  5. FAQ
  6. Sources

What a landlord insurance quote costs you

A quote gives you one number, the annual premium. What matters for a rental is that premium against the rent: its share of a year's rent, what it costs a month and how far it pulls down your cap rate and cash flow. No government body publishes an average landlord-insurance premium, so this page works only from the quotes you enter.

Share of rent=Annual premiumMonthly rent × 12
The example (inputs, not market data)
Quote 1Quote 2
Annual premium$1,650$1,420
Per month$137.50$118.33
Share of $24,000 rent6.9%5.9%
Cap rate after insurance5.45%5.53%

Insurance is one of the operating expenses in net operating income, so it lowers the cap rate directly; the NOI calculator itemizes the rest, and the rental cash flow calculator adds the mortgage payment.

Is landlord insurance tax deductible?

For a rental property, yes in most cases: IRS Publication 527 names insurance among the expenses of renting property that can be deducted from rental income, along with maintenance, taxes and interest. If you prepay a premium for more than one year, you deduct only the part that applies to each year of coverage.[1] The after-tax cost of a $1,420 premium:

After-tax cost of a $1,420 premium
Marginal tax rateAfter-tax cost
12%$1,250
22%$1,108
24%$1,079
32%$966

The same publication explains the passive activity and at-risk limits, which can delay the benefit when rental expenses exceed rental income.[1]

What to have ready for a landlord insurance quote

A landlord policy is usually a dwelling policy rather than a homeowners policy. New Jersey's insurance department describes the dwelling policy as property coverage only, for homes that do not qualify for homeowners insurance, and notes the building does not have to be occupied by the owner.[3] In Florida, Citizens offers its DP-3 for tenant-occupied properties, with loss of rent, and liability as an option.[2] Insurers price these from the same handful of facts, so gather them before you ask:

  • The building: address, year built, square footage, construction, roof age and material, number of units.
  • Occupancy: tenant-occupied, vacant or seasonal, and whether you let it long term or as a short-term rental.
  • Dwelling limit: what it would cost to rebuild, which is not the same as the market price.
  • Sections you want: other structures, your own contents in the unit, fair rental value (loss of rent), premises liability.
  • Deductibles: the all-perils deductible and, in coastal states, any separate wind or hurricane deductible.
  • Flood and earthquake: ask whether either is covered at all; flood is normally a separate policy.
  • Your lender's requirements: mortgagee clause and the minimum dwelling limit.

Most homeowners insurance does not cover flood, and an NFIP policy typically takes 30 days to start,[4] so price flood cover at the same time if the property needs it.

How to compare landlord insurance quotes

Two quotes only compare on price when the sections, limits and deductibles match. Check first which policy form each quote is on and how it settles a claim: landlord insurance policies explains the dwelling forms and works out what replacement cost and actual cash value pay on the same claim. In Florida, the separate hurricane deductible can matter more than the premium; the Florida landlord insurance worksheet turns each deductible option into dollars. In New Jersey, the New Jersey landlord insurance worksheet adds a flood policy to the quote, and landlord insurance California adds an earthquake policy and the FAIR Plan route. Letting in Australia or the UK? Their policies differ; see the Australian and UK versions.

Not adviceWe are not an insurer or broker. We do not sell, compare or arrange insurance, we do not rank insurers, and no insurer pays us. This page is general information, not insurance, tax or legal advice. In the US each state's insurance department licenses insurers and agents; check a company or agent with your state's department before you buy. See the investment disclaimer.

Frequently asked questions

How do I get a landlord insurance quote?

Ask licensed agents or insurers for a dwelling (landlord) policy and give each the same facts: the building, its occupancy, the dwelling limit, the sections you want and the deductibles. Then enter each annual premium in the worksheet.

What is a good landlord insurance quote?

There is no official benchmark premium. Judge a quote by its share of your rent, its effect on the cap rate and what it covers; the cheapest quote with a smaller limit or a higher deductible is not the same cover.

Can I deduct landlord insurance on my taxes?

In most cases, yes: IRS Publication 527 lists insurance among deductible rental expenses. A premium paid more than a year ahead is deducted year by year.

Should I quote landlord insurance with flood cover?

If the property could flood, yes. Most homeowners insurance does not cover flood and an NFIP policy usually has a 30-day waiting period, so a flood quote belongs with the landlord quote.

Sources

  1. Publication 527 (2025), Residential Rental Property · Internal Revenue Service, for 2025 returns
  2. Residential Policies (DP-1 and DP-3 dwelling fire) · Citizens Property Insurance Corporation, accessed November 15, 2026
  3. Everything You Wanted to Know about Buying a Home (Step 5: Insuring Your Home) · New Jersey Department of Banking and Insurance, 2012
  4. Flood Insurance · Federal Emergency Management Agency, October 20, 2026